A law firm which offers more

Call us: 0113 246 0622

Constructive dismissal claim: Understanding the ‘final straw’ argument


An employee can resign if you breach the contract of employment and make a constructive dismissal claim. A breach does not have to be one event.

It can be a series of events, with the employee resigning in response to one event which is seen as a ‘final straw’.

In Pets at Home v McKenzie [2018] the employee was an Assistant Manager. When she was pregnant she applied for promotion to Deputy Manager but was unsuccessful. Whilst she was on maternity leave another opportunity for promotion arose. She applied but again she was unsuccessful. Some time later she heard that the other Assistant Manager had been promoted to Deputy Manager (this was actually untrue, he had passed an assessment centre but had not actually been promoted). She resigned, claiming constructive dismissal and arguing the other Assistant Manager’s promotion was ‘the final straw’.

Her claim was unsuccessful. The alleged breach of contract was the decision not to promote her to Deputy Manager. Nearly a year had passed since that had occurred, and therefore she was not able to make a constructive dismissal claim relying on that alleged breach. Hearing about the Assistant Manager supposedly being promoted was not a breach of contract and therefore could not be classed as a final straw.

Learning points:

If you have any questions about the blog, please contact Joanna Dodd on 0113 336 3318 or by email at joanna.dodd@clarionsolicitors.com.

Disclaimer: Anything posted on this blog is for general information only and is not intended to provide legal advice on any general or specific matter. Please refer to our terms and conditions for further information. Please contact the author of the blog if you would like to discuss the issues raised.